Tag: Protecting Renters Ordinance

How Chicago should regulate rental junk fees

This post was co-written with Steffany Bahamon.

Chicago is going to regulate rental fees no matter which renter protection ordinance City Council passes. Both the mayor’s Protecting Renters Ordinance (PRO) and the alternative introduced by Ald. Gilbert Villegas (FAIR) write new fee rules, and both sit on top of the same new state law. The question isn’t whether Chicago should regulate junk fees; it’s how the list of allowed fees works, whether landlords have to show their costs, and what happens to move-in fees.

Abundant Housing Illinois (AHIL) supports PRO’s fee structure with two changes: let tenants choose between a security deposit and move-in/move-out fees (never both), and replace fixed dollar caps with a “reasonable documented cost” standard. This is the companion to last week’s post on what Chicago’s rental registry should collect and how to pay for it. (These memos are posted here because the AHIL website is presently being transferred to a new system.)

What state law already does

HB 3564, passed in May 2026, added fee rules to the Illinois Landlord and Tenant Act, effective January 1, 2027. Every non-optional fee has to be disclosed on the first page of the lease, application fees are capped at $50 (a landlord can bill a higher third-party screening cost only with a receipt, within 14 days), and landlords can’t rename a fee to get around the rules. Springfield deliberately left move-in fees and security deposits to local governments, which is where PRO and FAIR come in.

PRO and FAIR take opposite approaches

PRO says a tenant can be charged a security deposit, up to one month of prepaid rent, and a specific list of allowed fees. Everything else is out. FAIR does the reverse: it bans specific practices and permits the rest.

FAIRPRO
StructureBans listed practices, permits the restOnly listed fees are allowed (an “allow list”)
Application fee$50, with documented overage billable (state law)The lesser of the actual cost or $20
Move-in/move-out feesMove-in fee allowed if reasonably related to estimated costNot on the list, which means they’re banned
Security deposit cap1.5 months’ rent1 month’s rent
Proof of costFirst-page disclosure onlyItemized cost and documentation before charging
Routine maintenance (like repainting units, replacing worn fixtures, vacuuming)Barred only in pet chargesBarred from every fee
Utilities and RUBSNo markupNo markup building-wide, no billing-vendor fees, a written formula showing how utility bills are divided among apartments, 90 days’ notice of changes, bills on request

FAIR has a no-rename clause, but it only catches relabeling an existing fee, not inventing a new one. Under a “ban list” approach, a landlord who comes up with a fee nobody thought to ban gets to keep charging it.

An allow list is a typical policy

PRO’s approach isn’t radical. It’s similar to what many other places already do:

  • Seattle updated its rental fee rules in August 2026. A fee is legal only if city code or state law authorizes it, regardless of what it’s called. Seattle is stricter than PRO: no pet fees beyond a damage deposit, a flat $10 late fee, and no fees for paying by check or ACH.
  • Montgomery County, Maryland permits only an enumerated set of regulated fees.
  • Colorado bars fees above the landlord’s actual cost and requires a disclosed utility formula.

Utility billing rules

A ratio utility billing system (RUBS) splits a master-metered building’s utility bill across units by formula, usually based on apartment size and number of occupants (the assumption being that households of similar size use similar amounts of energy). Both ordinances keep RUBS legal. FAIR has one rule: no markups. PRO puts guardrails around it:

  • No markup across the building. The total charged to all tenants can’t exceed what the utilities billed.
  • No billing-vendor fees. Tenants can’t be charged costs from third-party vendors, aggregators, or resellers.
  • No switching mid-lease. A landlord can’t move a tenant from landlord-paid to tenant-paid utilities, or from fixed-rate to variable-rate, during the lease.
  • 90 days’ notice before any such change.
  • A written formula detailed enough for tenants to calculate their own share, keyed to the Tenant Utility Payment Disclosure Act.
  • Bills on request for any period a tenant is charged for.

That’s Seattle’s current position, and close to Oregon’s statewide rules. We support PRO’s approach to utilities as written.

Change 1: a deposit or move-in/move-out fees, never both

A common problem with junk fees is stacking: a move-in fee, an application charge, and a monthly “bundle” fee piled on top of base rent before anyone has moved in. PRO fixes this by banning move-in and move-out fees outright and capping deposits at one month’s rent.

We’d rather let tenants choose one track or the other. The landlord prices both up front, and the renter picks at signing:

  • Deposit track: a refundable security deposit of up to one and a half months’ rent (FAIR’s level), held and returned under the city’s Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance.
  • Fee track: move-in and/or move-out fees at reasonable documented cost, with a combined total of no more than one and a half months’ rent, and no deposit.

A move-in fee at cost is usually a few hundred dollars, not a month’s rent, so the fee track is a cheaper way into an apartment. The either/or rule ends stacking and should mean fewer fights over deposits.

Seattle caps the security deposit and nonrefundable move-in fees together at one month’s rent but leaves the mix up to the landlord. We’d hand that choice to the tenant. Cook County’s Residential Tenant Landlord Ordinance bars disguising a deposit as a nonrefundable fee, and we’d keep that rule: a fee that works like a deposit gets treated like one. A renter who wants money back picks the deposit; one who’s short on cash picks the fee. Capping the fee at documented cost keeps the cheaper option honest.

Change 2: reasonable documented cost, not fixed dollar caps

A cost standard is preferable because it’s based on real costs, while fixed dollar caps written into the ordinance will go stale. PRO already requires an itemized description, the cost, and supporting documentation before any fee is charged. A fee backed by receipts is easier to audit than a flat number nobody has to justify.

What we mean by “reasonable cost”:

  • What the landlord actually paid; for turnover fees, a documented estimate from recent turnovers of comparable units
  • No routine maintenance, overhead, or profit
  • Itemized and documented before it’s charged

For application fees, we’d use the state framework from HB 3564 instead of PRO’s $20 cap. That gives Illinois one application fee standard instead of two. Evanston and Cook County already use cost-based standards for move-in fees.

The fee schedule AHIL supports

Before move-in, a landlord may collect only:

  • First month’s rent
  • An application fee at actual documented cost, under the state framework (up to the $50 cap in state law, plus documented third-party overage, and free when the tenant provides a reusable screening report)
  • The tenant’s choice of one of the following (the landlord offers both, with prices in writing before signing):
    • a refundable security deposit of up to one and a half months’ rent, or
    • move-in and/or move-out fees at reasonable documented cost, with a combined total of no more than one and a half months’ rent

During the tenancy, only:

  • A pet fee, one-time or recurring but not both, at reasonable cost
  • Non-recurring costs the tenant triggers (key copies, bounced payments), at actual cost
  • Optional services the tenant opts into in writing, at cost
  • Utility charges under PRO’s rules: no markup building-wide, no billing-vendor fees, a written allocation formula, 90 days’ notice of changes, and bills on request

Rules for every fee:

  • Allow list: anything not on this list is prohibited
  • Itemized description, cost, and documentation before charging
  • No routine maintenance in any fee
  • Every non-optional fee on page one of the lease (state law)
  • A fee that works like a deposit is treated as a deposit (meaning it’s returned after the tenant moves out and leaves the unit in the condition previously agreed upon)
  • Charging a prohibited fee draws a penalty from the new rental housing bureau of 1.5 times the amount charged

Who else supports junk fee reform

Junk fee reform has been backed by other YIMBY groups, research organizations, and economists:

  • Open New York backed the FARE Act, New York City’s ban on making tenants pay broker fees for brokers the landlord hired. Executive Director Annemarie Gray said the law will protect renters from thousands of dollars in broker fees they never asked for.
  • Urban Institute recommends upfront disclosure of all fees, banning catch-all cost transfer clauses, banning mandatory services, and allowing evictions only for unpaid rent. Seattle’s council sponsor cited this research when the city unanimously passed its rental junk fee ban in August 2026.
  • Center for American Progress proposes capping rental application fees, noting that landlords typically pay screening companies less than they charge renters, and that portable screening report laws often produce limited savings in practice.
  • Neale Mahoney, a Stanford economist, worked on national junk fee policy in the Biden administration and flew to Seattle to testify for the city’s rental fee ban.

City Council should pass fee rules that list what a landlord can charge, require receipts for every charge, and let renters choose between a deposit and move-in fees instead of paying both. PRO gets most of the way there; with these two changes, Chicago would have one of the clearest fee standards in the country.

Chicago’s Protecting Renters Ordinance would create the rental registry the city needs

Update July 15, 2026: Mayor Johnson introduced the Protecting Renters Ordinance as number O2026-0026554 on June 29, 2026. Today, City That Works wrote about the pros and cons and potential positive and negative impacts of the proposed legislation.

I’ve written twice about why Chicago should have a rental registry — first proposing a kludge using existing county databases in 2023, then laying out the full rationale in 2024. Now, Mayor Brandon Johnson has proposed a rental registry as part of the Protecting Renters Ordinance, or PRO.

PRO is a comprehensive modernization of the Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance (RLTO). That law was first enacted during the Harold Washington administration and has hardly been updated since. Chicago’s rental market in 2026 looks nothing like it did in 1986: according to a fact sheet provided by the mayor’s office 622,000 families rent in Chicago today, about 54 percent of all households. Nearly half of them — 48 percent — are cost-burdened, meaning they spend more than 30 percent of their income on housing. Rents have risen 10 percent year over year.

And 12 percent of Chicago’s 2-to-6-unit buildings — the city’s classic two-flats and three-flats — are now owned by LLCs, a share that has grown as corporate investors have entered the market. Housing costs have now surpassed crime as the top concern among Chicago voters, with 41 percent naming affordability as their primary issue in a March 2026 Illinois REALTORS poll — compared to 23 percent for crime.

The city has no rental registry and no just-cause eviction protection. PRO proposes to change both, and more.

Five components

  1. Rental registry — Requires annual registration of all non-owner-occupied rental units, creating a citywide data infrastructure and connecting LLC entities to the real people behind them.
  2. Bureau of Rental Housing Services (BRH) — The city’s first dedicated office for RLTO code enforcement. Right now, tenants who want to enforce their rights have to hire their own attorney. The BRH would handle complaint processing, investigation, and enforcement coordination. It would also provide compliance support for small landlords. It would be funded by rental registry fees — not the general fund.
  3. RLTO modernization and tenant rights — Updates the underlying law and cleans up its language. Bans junk fees. Caps application fees at $20 (unless a credit or background check costs more). Addresses utility pass-throughs, known as Ratio Utility Billing Systems (RUBS): landlords could only charge tenants the exact utility cost. Reforms security deposits and administrative fees. Consolidates existing tenant rights into a Tenant Bill of Rights — none of these rights would be new, but the consolidation would make them easier to understand and enforce. Maintenance and upkeep costs could not be passed on to tenants as fees.
  4. Eviction Counsel Program — Codifies the existing Right to Counsel pilot program, giving it permanent legal authority. The program is currently run by the Law Center for Better Housing at an annual cost of about $4 million. It returns an estimated $2.75 to $3.35 in fiscal benefits for every $1 invested — about $13.6 million in cumulative benefits since 2022. This piece would not be funded by the rental registry and would need a budget appropriation starting in 2028.
  5. Just Cause for Eviction — Requires landlords to provide a valid reason for eviction or non-renewal, with relocation assistance required when tenants are displaced without cause. The city estimates this would protect about 10,000 families per year.

The rental registry in depth

The rental registry is the component that makes many of PRO’s other components workable. Right now, Chicago has no comprehensive record of its more than 500,000 rental units — who owns them or how many there are in a given building. As I noted in my 2024 post, the city’s complaint-based inspection system misses dangerous situations in part because tenants fear retaliation. A registry shifts the city from being almost always reactive to possible being more proactive.

The registry would require landlords to renew annually and pay a fee ranging from $20 to $60 per unit, scaled to building size, according to The Real Deal. The city estimates this would generate about $20 million annually — enough to fund the Bureau of Rental Housing Services and its enforcement work without drawing on the general fund. Owner-occupied 2-to-6-unit buildings, CHA housing, and nonprofit affordable housing would be exempt from fees, but not from the registration requirement itself. The distinction matters: the city still wants to know those units exist, even if it isn’t charging those owners.

The registry would give the city a tool it currently lacks for understanding patterns: tracking building violations over time, identifying landlords with repeat problems, and spotting speculation in gentrifying neighborhoods where investors are acquiring properties without maintaining them. The Sun-Times reported that the city specifically cited this use case — the registry as a way to “start tracking patterns and understanding trends.”

Chicago would not be the first Illinois city to do this. Rockford, Urbana, Champaign, and Evanston all have rental registries. New York City, Philadelphia, Los Angeles, Washington DC, and Detroit are the national comparables the city cited. New York has three registries — for rent-stabilized units, short-term rentals, and a general one. Chicago’s would be modeled on that general type, focused on data collection and transparency rather than rent regulation.

The ordinance as proposed is focused on registration and enforcement, but I see opportunities to expand what the registry tracks. Could it record evictions as they happen, building a running citywide record rather than relying on court data retrieved years after the event? Courts will provide eviction data, but only historically — a live registry linked to eviction filings would be far more useful for spotting patterns in real time.

Could it also serve as a public-facing database of available apartments, including units created through the city’s Affordable Requirements Ordinance? ARO units are notoriously difficult for renters to find. The city publishes an ARO buildings database but people who qualify for an ARO apartment must contact each building manager individually to ascertain availability. A registry designed with these uses in mind from the start could solve so many longstanding issues with finding housing.

Where things stand

PRO is still a work in progress and the ordinance text hasn’t been finalized. The city has been briefing advocacy organizations and apartment industry groups to gather feedback, and is hoping to introduce the ordinance in late June.

I’ll write more as the ordinance advances. The rental registry is the piece I care most about in this series — it’s the data foundation without which the rest of PRO is difficult to enforce.