Category: Trains

Chicago wants to buy three Union Pacific properties before they’re sold for parts

Two huge American railroads, Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern, want to merge, which would have huge impacts on hundreds of cities across the country. The two railroads, combined, would be the largest by a wide margin and federal law requires that the Surface Transportation Board approve the merger.

Tucked into the City of Chicago’s 64-page comments on the proposed Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger is a situation that caught my eye. Among its requested conditions for the STB, the City asks that UP conclude negotiations to sell the Weber Spur to the city and “enter into negotiations with the City for the City’s acquisition of UP’s Low Line and Global 1 Yard.”

Excerpt from page 16 of the City of Chicago's merger comments, Requested Condition #9, asking that Union Pacific sell the Weber Spur to the City for a 2-mile trail and negotiate the sale of its Low Line and Global 1 Yard.

Global 1

Global 1 is the former intermodal terminal (where shipping containers moved between trains and trucks) at 1425 S Western Ave, which covers 123 acres. UP moved that work to Global 2 in suburban Northlake in 2023.

Map of Union Pacific's Global I intermodal yard on Chicago's Near West Side, on a light gray street grid with streets labeled. The yard is shaded teal with a solid outline: a wide block at its west end, starting at Western Avenue between about 14th and 16th streets, that narrows to a long strip running east past Ashland and Racine to near Morgan Street, just short of Halsted. Dotted gray lines show freight railroad tracks running through the yard and alongside it, with a dense bundle curving southwest past Western Avenue. The Metra BNSF line, in blue, runs along the yard's south edge through the Western Ave. and Halsted St. stations. The CTA Pink Line, in pink, runs south through the yard at about Paulina Street to its 18th station, then turns west toward Damen. Small green parks are scattered across the neighborhood. A legend in the lower left lists railroads, the CTA Pink Line, the Metra BNSF line, the yard (123 acres) and transit stations. A box in the lower right holds the title and the data sources: OpenStreetMap, the Federal Railroad Administration, the CTA and Metra.

There could be a number of uses, including breaking it up into smaller parcels for businesses that need a lot of outdoor land. You could also put a bus garage there. It would be a tragedy if it was used for distribution warehouses.

If the White Sox’s future owner buys the 14th Street rail yard from Amtrak for a stadium, Metra might also need somewhere new for its trains, and Global 1 is close by. The proposed O’Hare Flyer has also said it’s counting on freed-up land at the yard for trains to layover.

The Low Line

The Low Line is UP track near the former Blommer Chocolate factory on Kinzie Street in River West. The City’s North Branch Framework proposes a north-south transitway running from the downtown train stations up the North Branch to north of North Avenue, and a railroad right-of-way the City owns could become part of it.

It’s also a natural spot for the north portal of a CrossTowner tunnel, where trains coming from the south would climb out of the Clinton–Roosevelt Connector and continue north. You can see what that ride might look like in my virtual cab ride video.

That’s a lot of potential suitors for two rail properties. Whether the STB folds the City’s request into its decision is something to watch as the merger review continues. Replies to the comments are due February 16, 2027.

The Weber Spur

The headline request is the former Weber Spur in Northwest Chicago. The city asks the STB to require UP to “conclude negotiations” for the city to buy it, and says it proposes “an approximately 2-mile long multi-use trail in the former railroad right-of-way.” Streetsblog Chicago published an update about this project last month.

The city frames the purchase as a community benefit “at no cost to Applicants”. This reminds me of when the railroad that owned the Bloomingdale Line was happy to transfer the embankment to the city, to build the 606, as soon as possible – the property was a liability to the railroad but a benefit for the city.

Read Ryan Richter’s thread about what went into the comments that the city and partners submitted to the STB.

Here are the next steps, per STB:

  • Nov 27, 2026: Comments due on whether competing railroads’ applications are complete.
  • Dec 1, 2026: Replies to those comments are due.
  • Dec 3, 2026: The U.S. Department of Justice and USDOT file preliminary comments.
  • Dec 4, 2026: UP must answer the STB’s questions about alleged retaliation against opponents.
  • Feb 16, 2027: UP and NS respond to all comments and requests for conditions.
  • Mar 29, 2027: Competing railroads file rebuttals.
  • Spring 2027 (date TBD): The STB holds a public hearing.
  • May 28, 2027: Final briefs are due, and the record closes after that.
  • About Aug–Sept 2027: The STB aims to decide within 90 days, if the environmental review is finished.

Take a virtual ride on a future regional train in Chicago

I’m not talking about the Chicago Flyer.

Take a virtual ride in the cab of a CrossTowner X1 train from the Metra Electric tracks near 18th Street, down into the proposed Clinton–Roosevelt Connector tunnel, out at Chicago Avenue, and onto Metra’s Union Pacific North tracks to Clybourn, stopping at Roosevelt, Taylor/Clinton, Union Station West, Randolph/Clinton (Ogilvie), Chicago/Halsted, and Division/Elston.

The CrossTowner is a proposal from Star:Line Chicago for thru-running regional rail across Chicagoland. Learn more at buildthetunnelchicago.org.

This animation runs at 4× the speed of the proposed “X1” line’s synthetic schedule, and the tunnel, stations, and train are illustrative.

Plan a trip on the proposed network using the R5-based trip planner I made using the CrossTowner synthetic schedules and network map.

Metra’s own regional rail plan is open for comments

Meanwhile, Metra is figuring out how far it can get on the tracks it already has. In October the agency released a draft of its Systemwide Network Plan (SNP), a line-by-line study of the work and cost it would take to run frequent, all-day trains in both directions (what’s called regional rail, or RER and S-bahn in other countries) instead of a schedule built mostly around getting people to central Chicago at rush hour.

Highlights from the draft:

  • Two tiers of service. “Regional Rail 1.0” would run trains every 30 to 60 minutes. “Regional Rail 2.0,” with more investment, would run them every 15 to 30 minutes.
  • The price tag. Regional Rail 1.0 would cost $2.7 billion in capital and $269 million in additional operating costs. Getting to 2.0 would cost another $6.4 billion in capital and $411 million more in operating costs.
  • No one-size-fits-all. Some lines would keep today’s pattern, just with more trains. Others might split into an inner zone and an outer zone (which is also something that CrossTowner proposes).
  • Mostly within Metra’s existing footprint. The plan largely avoids buying new right-of-way or adding mainline tracks beyond what’s already planned.
  • O’Hare connections. The plan would, for the first time, connect the south and west suburbs directly to O’Hare Airport, according to the Chicago Sun-Times.
  • It’s required now. The law that created the Northern Illinois Transit Authority (NITA) requires Metra to run a regional rail pilot on the Rock Island Line by January 2027.

Metra held a virtual public meeting about the plan on Monday, November 16. As of Tuesday, Metra hasn’t posted a recording of it on the SNP page or on its YouTube channel (it did post the video of its May 2024 SNP meeting).

You can still weigh in in writing until December 14. Read the draft report, then submit comments using Metra’s feedback form. Tell Metra which line you’d use, where and when you’d go if trains came every 15 or 30 minutes.

How this video animation was made

The ride is a 3D scene built in three.js (Claude Code wrote all of the JavaScript) and rendered frame by frame to 4K video with HyperFrames. The buildings come from OpenStreetMap, using each one’s mapped height, color and roof shape. The train follows the Clinton–Roosevelt Connector alignment, rebuilt as straight segments joined by curves. North of Chicago Avenue it joins the UP North’s existing tracks, traced from OpenStreetMap.

The train’s motion comes from a physics model (see the code used) of a four-car Stadler FLIRT. The figures used: about 160 tons, 2.6 megawatts (roughly 3,500 horsepower), 45,000 pounds of pull at starting, and a top speed of 99 mph (although the max speed in the simulated ride is 75 mph because that’s what can be reached in the distances shown in the route).

Line chart of train speed against distance over the 1,524 meters from 18th Street (Soldier Field) to Roosevelt. A blue line shows a Stadler FLIRT at full power: it climbs to 65 mph at 32 seconds, brakes to 32 mph for a 140-meter-radius curve under Roosevelt Road, speeds up to 44 mph at 78 seconds, then brakes to a stop. The trip takes 98 seconds. An orange line shows the film's schedule: it holds about 32.5 mph most of the way and brakes to a stop at Roosevelt, taking 120 seconds.

Leaving each platform, the train accelerates as hard as its motors allow. It then brakes at a normal service rate into the next stop. On every curve it slows to the speed federal track safety rules allow for that curve’s radius (49 CFR 213.57). The stops last one minute each, and the whole ride plays at 4x speed.

The sound was generated by programs on my computer. The announcements use macOS’s built-in text to speech (I selected Zoe, Enhanced). Each chime is a formula of decaying sine waves that ffmpeg turns into audio. The rumble is filtered noise, built in Python: it swells with the train’s speed, gets louder in the tunnel, and carries a motor whine that climbs in pitch as the train speeds up. A script reads the stop times from the synthetic schedule and the physics model and lines up the announcements, chimes and captions to match.

How to map where I traveled when I went to Gorinchem, NL

On Monday, December 4, 2023, I wanted to ride a line in the Netherlands that I hadn’t yet, which is called the “MerwedeLingelijn” and goes between Dordrecht and Geldermalsen. In the NS journey planner database it’s called “Stoptrein” which distinguishes it from “Sprinter” and “Intercity”. Those names distinguish the service types on the Dutch railway network. (This particular Stoptrein is also a diesel-electric trainset.)

From Rotterdam, where I was staying, it would require at least one transfer to get to Gorinchem. But I wanted to stop in Utrecht to say hi to a friend during his work break – this meant there would be two transfers.

Here’s the itinerary I traveled on Monday

  • Rotterdam Centraal to Utrecht Centraal via Gouda, Intercity (half-hourly service) – 55 km
  • Utrecht Centraal to Geldermalsen, Sprinter (10-20 minute service) – 26 km
  • Geldermalsen to Gorinchem, Stoptrein (half-hourly service) – 27 km
  • [lunch and walk in Gorinchem, distance not recorded]
  • Gorinchem to Dordrecht, Stoptrein (quarter-hourly service) – 24 km
  • Dordrecht to Rotterdam, Waterbus (hourly service) – 21 km

How I drew the map

I wasn’t about to draw the routes by hand (although I did record the Waterbus ride on Strava as a “sail”) so I grabbed the data from OpenStreetMap.

If you want data in bulk from OpenStreetMap a common way to get it is from the HotOSM export tool. But I wanted specific transit routes, for which I could find the “way” IDs and export only those. For that I used Overpass Turbo and wrote the following query:

[out:json][timeout:25];
// gather results
rel(id:324888,13060594,5301520,2785504);
way(r);
// print results
out geom;

Notes

Frequencies refer to the pattern in the hour I used the service. The itinerary doesn’t include a Rotterdam Metro ride or the roundtrip bike ride from the Schiebroek neighborhood to Rotterdam Centraal).

Starting on December 10, the NS (Dutch national railway operator) is adding over 1,800 train services each week.

A short list of features of the Netherlands that I still try to wrap my head around

The Netherlands is the country I’ve visited the most, going there eight times between 2011 and 2022. I’ve obsessively visited 31 cities, the Hoge Veluwe national park, and plenty of other places outside cities.

Here are three land use and infrastructure characteristics that continue to fascinate me.

Transportation systems, obviously

Learning about how the Dutch created the safest network of streets for cycling is what started my near-obsession 15 years ago.

Then I went there in 2011 and I got to experience it for myself (photos from that trip).

I think the quality, capacity, likability, and integration of their transportation systems can be summarized best, for Americans who haven’t been there, by learning the results of a Waze survey: People who primarily drive in the Netherlands are more satisfied with the driving in their country than people in other countries are with driving in theirs.

In other words…if you like driving, then you should also care about what the Netherlands because they happened to also create the most driver-friendly transportation system.

Creating land & living with flooded land

As a novice, it’s probably easier to notice and understand how the Dutch create, move, and live with flooded land from above. There have been moments while I was cycling in the country where I’ve ridden past “polders” and former lakes and seas only to realize it later that I had biked through a massively transformed area that appeared entirely natural.

When I lived in Rotterdam for three months in 2016 I tried to visit as many places across the country as I could. I especially wanted to visit Flevopolder, the larger part of the Flevoland province, built from of the sea in 1986 where 317,000 people live.

I visited both major cities on the Flevopolder in the same day, Almere and Lelystad, the capital. I cycled from Almere (photos) to the seafront of Markermeer, and…get this…had to ride uphill because the land is below sea level.

Reaching the edge of Flevopolder, where it borders the sea called Markermeer
Cycling uphill to meet the sea north of the city of Almere, in the Flevoland province of the Netherlands.

Most Dutchies live below sea level, and the country has massive land and metal engineering works to keep the water in check.

The Dutch, especially in and around Rotterdam, come up with new ways to deal with water and export this knowledge abroad.

While the existing and planned measures should be sufficient until at least 2070, too much uncertainty over the progress of climate change remains afterwards to assess whether the city will truly stay liveable.

Some assessments suggest that if the sea rises by 5m – an estimate in sight within a century, considering the unpredictability of the rate that Greenland and Antarctica’s glacier will melt – Rotterdam will have no other choice but to relocate.

“Rotterdam: A bastion against rising sea, for now”
By Zuza Nazaruk

The country may rely on electricity to survive more than most: it’s needed to keep the pumps working, to keep the water in the sea instead of in and over the land.

How productive their agriculture industry is

By land area, the Netherlands is a very small country; it would be the tenth smallest state in the United States. By population, it would be the fifth largest state (17.6 million, greater than Pennsylvania’s 13 million).

Given that, how is it that the Netherlands is the world’s second largest exporter of agricultural products by value, after the United States?

Simple answer: High-quality, high-value, high-demand foodstuffs; space-efficient farming practices, including a significant amount of food grown vertically and in greenhouses. And, I don’t remember if this was in the article, very good transport connections to trading partners through seaports, canals, railways, and motorways.

I was surprised to see that both brands of canned cold brew coffee sold at the convenience store in my apartment building are produced in the Netherlands.

I tried to see the Vatican City train station

Vatican City has a train station but you cannot see it. You can, however, see the large gates within the papal state’s wall that enclose the train station and separate it from the main railway network in Italy. 

Beyond the gates is the Vatican City railway station
Beyond the gates is the Vatican City railway station

The Citta Vaticano railway station is on a branch on the Roma-Capranica-Viterbo mainline and nominally connected to the Roma San Pietro train station which serves Trenitalia regional trains, including the numbered Lazio region commuter lines. 

Railway branch to Vatican City

There is one way to visit the train station and that’s to take a Vatican City-sponsored day trip from the station to the Pontifical Villages about 15 miles southeast of Rome. In 2022, the trips are offered on Saturdays through October 29 and cost about €43. 

A proposal intended for visitors interested in taking part in a tour of the Vatican City and the Gardens of the Pontifical Villas of Castel Gandolfo.

Every Saturday, a modern and comfortable electric train connects the historic Vatican City railway station with the Pontifical Villas for a Full Day visit that, starting with the wonders of the Vatican Museums and continuing through the Vatican Gardens, will lead the visitor to discover the Gardens of the Pontifical Villas.

Pope Francis opened the villas and Castel Gandolfo in 2015. Watch an AFP video in English or in French about the news.

Watch this video from The Round the World Guys – skip to 5:58 – for a view of the station and their ride to the villas. (I thought The Tim Traveller also made a video about the Vatican City railway station but I cannot find it on his YouTube channel.)

When I was in Rome this month – part of a longer trip to Rome, Florence, Lyon, Strasbourg, the Netherlands, and Germany – I wanted to see what I could see, so I walked south and west around the wall towards the San Pietro station. A street follows the southern wall; walk along this and you’ll come to an entry to a railroad viaduct. At this point, it’s at ground level, but to the left (south) the ground quickly slopes down several stories. The viaduct holds the branch from the main line and you can walk across it to San Pietro station. 

If that’s too difficult to follow, go to the San Pietro station, go up to binario (platform) 1, and walk towards the large St. Peter’s Basilica you see to the right.

Railway to Vatican City