Category: Urban Planning

The Zoning Board of Appeals approves almost everything, so why make small businesses wait for it?

If you want to open a hair salon in a Chicago storefront that’s zoned for business, you can, as long as there isn’t another salon within 1,000 feet1. If there is, you need a special use permit from the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA). That means paperwork, mailed notices, often hiring an attorney, attending an official hearing, possibly being part of a ward-level community presentation, and potentially paying rent for months on a space you can’t open. And for all that, the ZBA approves 95 percent of salon applications.

That number comes from the Metropolitan Planning Council’s (MPC) new report, At What Cost? How Chicago’s Outdated Zoning and Land Use Systems Thwart Inclusive Growth, published in October 2026. It arrives while a proposal to fix part of this problem has sat untouched in City Council for nearly two years. In December 2024, Ald. Desmon Yancy introduced an ordinance to let the zoning administrator approve many special uses directly, without a ZBA hearing. It still hasn’t been heard in committee.

I first wrote about Yancy’s proposal in a Bluesky thread the week before it was introduced. MPC’s research makes the case for it stronger than I could at the time.

What is a “special use”?

Chicago’s zoning code sorts every building type, business, or land use into one of three buckets in each zoning district: permitted “by right,” not allowed, or allowed as a “special use.” A special use is allowed only after a review that decides whether that particular location suits it. Today that review means a public hearing before the ZBA, a board of mayoral appointees.

MPC calls the ZBA process “complex” and “lengthy,” says it often requires the help of an attorney, and concludes that its “opacity… and lack of consistent guidelines” favor applicants with time and money, “creating a pay-to-play system.” (Based on my observations at ZBA meetings most hair salon applicants represent themselves and the ZBA board members accommodate them and how they are not as familiar with the processes as other applicants who’ve hired attorneys.)

The ZBA approves nearly everything

MPC built its own dataset from 12 years of ZBA meeting minutes (through October 2023). The city doesn’t publish this data in a searchable format, so MPC’s staff had to pull it from hundreds of PDFs. Here’s what they found:

FindingFigure
Share of all ZBA applications approved92% (only 3–4% are explicitly denied; the rest are withdrawn)
Votes in which the board was unanimous96%
Special use applications reviewed per yearAbout 230
Special use applications coming from business (B) and commercial (C) districts78%
Special use applications for hair, nail, or beauty salons and barbershops27%
Salon and barbershop applications approved95%
Salon and barbershop applications decided at their first hearing90%

Translation: more than a quarter of the board’s special use docket is salons and barbershops, and they’re approved almost every time. That sounds like a toll that every applicant pays. MPC also points out who pays it: 91 percent of hairdressers and cosmetologists are women, and nail salon workers are mostly immigrants, so the 1,000-foot rule likely falls hardest on women-owned and immigrant-owned small businesses.

I’d like to know why City Council cares about how close two salons are to each other and wanted to regulate that.

What Yancy’s ordinance would change

The ordinance (O2024-0014002) was introduced on December 2, 2024, and co-sponsored by Alderpersons Rodriguez (22nd Ward), Villegas (36th), and Hadden (49th). It amends Section 17-13-0900 of the zoning code so that the zoning administrator, a DPD staff position, decides special use applications instead of only sending a recommendation to the ZBA.

The ZBA would keep the final say on:

  • anything in a manufacturing (M) or planned manufacturing district (PMD)
  • special uses requiring compliance with the Air Quality Ordinance
  • drive-throughs
  • waste-related uses
  • cannabis establishments
  • gas stations
  • liquor stores
  • adult uses

Everything else that’s a special use today would go to the zoning administrator:

CategorySpecial uses that would move to the zoning administrator
HousingGround-floor homes in B1, B3, C1, and C2 districts (detached houses, two-flats, townhouses, multi-unit buildings, elderly housing, and single-room occupancy); artist and business live/work units; residential conversion units; most housing types in the DX district, and multi-unit, elderly, and SRO housing in DC
Shelters and group livingTransitional residences, transitional shelters, temporary overnight shelters, domestic violence shelters and residences, group community homes, nursing homes, assisted living, and group living not otherwise classified
Neighborhood businessesHair salons, nail salons, and barbershops within 1,000 feet of another one; banks, currency exchanges, and ATMs subject to the pedestrian street rules; body art (tattoo) services; massage establishments; fortune telling; taverns and rooftop patios in B3; indoor event venues; entertainment cabarets; hookah bars; rooftop urban farms; hotels and motels
Civic and institutionalCommunity centers and recreation buildings (including in parks), religious assembly, schools, colleges in C3, lodges and private clubs, police stations, government-operated health centers in residential districts, major utilities, and detention and correctional facilities
Other usesPawn shops, payday and title loan stores, valuable objects dealers, firearms dealers, shooting ranges, wagering facilities, day labor employment agencies, and flea markets
Auto-oriented and otherNon-accessory parking lots, vehicle storage and towing, animal shelters and boarding kennels, stables, poultry slaughtering, cremation, freestanding wireless towers, satellite dishes beyond what’s allowed by right, and certain signs

Two more details stand out:

  • Public input stays. Applicants would still mail, publish, and post the same notices, and the public would get 30 days to send comments to the zoning administrator. What goes away is the daytime City Hall hearing.
  • There’s a deadline, and it has teeth. If the zoning administrator doesn’t decide within 120 days of a complete application, it’s automatically approved (unless the applicant caused the delay).

MPC’s suggestions would go further

Yancy’s ordinance and MPC’s recommendations point in the same direction, but MPC goes a step further. MPC recommends permitting “most current special use categories by-right, with accompanying use standards,” and saving ZBA review for “uses with likely impacts on health and safety,” like heavy manufacturing, waste processing, and adult uses. Salons, live-work spaces, and community centers would be “regulated like all other business types.”

(Use standards mean specific requirements the applicant would have to show when they get their business license or building permit. The same people who review those now would ensure that the applicant is planning to meet those specific requirements, and city inspectors would verify these things before the business gets approval to open for customers.)

The two also agree on housing. Exempting shelters and transitional residences from the ZBA was one of the recommendations in the city’s Cut the Tape report, and MPC recommends removing the special use requirement for single-room occupancy (SRO) buildings, shelters, and other group living, a requirement that MPC says “delays or blocks a necessary housing option… for our lowest-resourced neighbors.” This is also the position of Abundant Housing Illinois, which advocates for removing barriers to approving housing and for increasing affordable housing.

I wonder why some uses need a special zoning review at all: hookah bars are on the special use list yet regulating indoor smoking is a job for health and licensing rules, not zoning. That’s an argument for MPC’s approach: review each item in the special use list, permit the low-impact uses by right, and keep a real hearing for the few that need it.

What about the alderpersons?

The obvious objection is that the zoning administrator becomes the person angry alderpersons blame. Alderpersons wouldn’t get a formal sign-off under the ordinance, though they’d receive the same notice that nearby property owners get.

But MPC notes that alderpersons already aren’t officially part of the ZBA process, and yet “in practice, alders hold major sway in the outcome,” so special use applications “often require political support to move forward.” Moving the decision to staff, with a deadline, gives that informal pressure less room to work.

That’s part of why it’s notable that this proposal came from Ald. Yancy. His predecessor in the 5th Ward tried to rezone a stretch of the 71st Street commercial corridor to single-family residential, which would have given her a veto over any business that wanted to open there. Yancy is proposing to give some of that kind of power away.

Where it stands

The ordinance has not been heard in committee. One of its co-sponsors, Ald. Gilbert Villegas, now chairs the Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards. Villegas should give Yancy’s ordinance a hearing and the committee should pass it. Then the city planning department and committee should later take up MPC’s larger recommendation: write use standards into the code and let low-impact uses like salons open by right.

  1. There are 1,730 licensed hair, nail, and skin care locations in Chicago. The 1,112 in “B” districts are subject to the 1,000-foot proximity rule, and 84 percent of those are within 1,000 feet of another salon. Their median distance to the nearest salon is 336 feet. ↩︎

Chicago’s 2027 budget should make housing cheaper to build, not more expensive

Today, November 4, 2026, Chicago City Council’s Budget Committee is holding its hearing on the Department of Planning and Development’s 2027 budget.

Dear Budget Committee Chair Ervin and members of council. My name is Steven Vance, and I’m a volunteer lead with Abundant Housing Illinois. We’re 500 advocates in Chicago who have a laser focus on stopping the rapid increase in rents and getting more people housed.

There’s a way to raise revenue without imposing new costs: let more housing get built, sooner and faster.

New homes mean new property tax base, permit fees, and construction activity. That’s why I’m concerned about the proposed 33% increase in the lease tax in the 2027 budget. Construction equipment, much of it rented, will cost more. And every homebuilder and architect who uses QuickBooks, AutoCAD, or a payroll service will pay more. Raising the cost of doing business raises the cost of housing.

The other big barrier is process. Most new housing in Chicago is approved through the Planned Development process, the most expensive way to approve housing. Changes to the zoning code can get housing permitted faster and with lower-cost reviews. I’ll briefly describe three ideas to raise revenue by speeding up housing approvals, inspired by the landmark report from Metropolitan Planning Council about Chicago zoning practices, flaws, and opportunities.

  1. More alderpersons should opt in to allow accessory dwelling units, without block by block restrictions. Homeowners who decide to build an ADU pay a little more in property taxes and the neighborhood gets an additional home.
  2. City Council’s zoning and housing committees should approve the introduced ordinances that would let modest multifamily housing be permitted quicker and less expensively. Every month not building means high borrowing costs and a delay in the city receiving new property tax revenue. Not every home should need costly approvals from the City Council.
  3. Build on what’s working. Under Commissioner Boatright’s leadership, city-owned land sales have accelerated and improved. The Missing Middle Infill Housing program has restarted construction on blocks that haven’t seen a new home in decades. Part of that success was changing the zoning map ahead of time. Program participants, and others inspired by the new construction, can now build a three-flat without paying for special approval.

I’d ask Commissioners Ciere Boatright (Planning and Development) and Lissette Castañeda (Housing): what staffing resources do your departments need to develop housing more rapidly? Can city-owned land sales go even faster? What additional changes to the zoning map would jumpstart building more homes less expensively?

This budget should make housing cheaper to build, not more expensive. Funding faster approvals is an investment that pays for itself.

Thank you.

The ordinances

  • Enable more homes and cheaper construction by allowing a single stair in smaller apartment buildings – SO2025-0017571
  • Eliminate minimum lot area per unit in multi-unit districts; excludes family-sized units from floor area – O2026-0028842
  • Allow single room occupancy buildings (SROs) and shelters by right in mixed-use districts; ends the zoning code’s soft roommate ban (I wrote more about this one last month) – O2026-0029459
  • Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) applications can score higher by proposing lower costs per unit – O2026-0029453
  • Lets home builders and small businesses get administrative approval instead of special use approval for many uses – O2024-0014002

Chicago’s Protecting Renters Ordinance would create the rental registry the city needs

Update July 15, 2026: Mayor Johnson introduced the Protecting Renters Ordinance as number O2026-0026554 on June 29, 2026. Today, City That Works wrote about the pros and cons and potential positive and negative impacts of the proposed legislation.

I’ve written twice about why Chicago should have a rental registry — first proposing a kludge using existing county databases in 2023, then laying out the full rationale in 2024. Now, Mayor Brandon Johnson has proposed a rental registry as part of the Protecting Renters Ordinance, or PRO.

PRO is a comprehensive modernization of the Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance (RLTO). That law was first enacted during the Harold Washington administration and has hardly been updated since. Chicago’s rental market in 2026 looks nothing like it did in 1986: according to a fact sheet provided by the mayor’s office 622,000 families rent in Chicago today, about 54 percent of all households. Nearly half of them — 48 percent — are cost-burdened, meaning they spend more than 30 percent of their income on housing. Rents have risen 10 percent year over year.

And 12 percent of Chicago’s 2-to-6-unit buildings — the city’s classic two-flats and three-flats — are now owned by LLCs, a share that has grown as corporate investors have entered the market. Housing costs have now surpassed crime as the top concern among Chicago voters, with 41 percent naming affordability as their primary issue in a March 2026 Illinois REALTORS poll — compared to 23 percent for crime.

The city has no rental registry and no just-cause eviction protection. PRO proposes to change both, and more.

Five components

  1. Rental registry — Requires annual registration of all non-owner-occupied rental units, creating a citywide data infrastructure and connecting LLC entities to the real people behind them.
  2. Bureau of Rental Housing Services (BRH) — The city’s first dedicated office for RLTO code enforcement. Right now, tenants who want to enforce their rights have to hire their own attorney. The BRH would handle complaint processing, investigation, and enforcement coordination. It would also provide compliance support for small landlords. It would be funded by rental registry fees — not the general fund.
  3. RLTO modernization and tenant rights — Updates the underlying law and cleans up its language. Bans junk fees. Caps application fees at $20 (unless a credit or background check costs more). Addresses utility pass-throughs, known as Ratio Utility Billing Systems (RUBS): landlords could only charge tenants the exact utility cost. Reforms security deposits and administrative fees. Consolidates existing tenant rights into a Tenant Bill of Rights — none of these rights would be new, but the consolidation would make them easier to understand and enforce. Maintenance and upkeep costs could not be passed on to tenants as fees.
  4. Eviction Counsel Program — Codifies the existing Right to Counsel pilot program, giving it permanent legal authority. The program is currently run by the Law Center for Better Housing at an annual cost of about $4 million. It returns an estimated $2.75 to $3.35 in fiscal benefits for every $1 invested — about $13.6 million in cumulative benefits since 2022. This piece would not be funded by the rental registry and would need a budget appropriation starting in 2028.
  5. Just Cause for Eviction — Requires landlords to provide a valid reason for eviction or non-renewal, with relocation assistance required when tenants are displaced without cause. The city estimates this would protect about 10,000 families per year.

The rental registry in depth

The rental registry is the component that makes many of PRO’s other components workable. Right now, Chicago has no comprehensive record of its more than 500,000 rental units — who owns them or how many there are in a given building. As I noted in my 2024 post, the city’s complaint-based inspection system misses dangerous situations in part because tenants fear retaliation. A registry shifts the city from being almost always reactive to possible being more proactive.

The registry would require landlords to renew annually and pay a fee ranging from $20 to $60 per unit, scaled to building size, according to The Real Deal. The city estimates this would generate about $20 million annually — enough to fund the Bureau of Rental Housing Services and its enforcement work without drawing on the general fund. Owner-occupied 2-to-6-unit buildings, CHA housing, and nonprofit affordable housing would be exempt from fees, but not from the registration requirement itself. The distinction matters: the city still wants to know those units exist, even if it isn’t charging those owners.

The registry would give the city a tool it currently lacks for understanding patterns: tracking building violations over time, identifying landlords with repeat problems, and spotting speculation in gentrifying neighborhoods where investors are acquiring properties without maintaining them. The Sun-Times reported that the city specifically cited this use case — the registry as a way to “start tracking patterns and understanding trends.”

Chicago would not be the first Illinois city to do this. Rockford, Urbana, Champaign, and Evanston all have rental registries. New York City, Philadelphia, Los Angeles, Washington DC, and Detroit are the national comparables the city cited. New York has three registries — for rent-stabilized units, short-term rentals, and a general one. Chicago’s would be modeled on that general type, focused on data collection and transparency rather than rent regulation.

The ordinance as proposed is focused on registration and enforcement, but I see opportunities to expand what the registry tracks. Could it record evictions as they happen, building a running citywide record rather than relying on court data retrieved years after the event? Courts will provide eviction data, but only historically — a live registry linked to eviction filings would be far more useful for spotting patterns in real time.

Could it also serve as a public-facing database of available apartments, including units created through the city’s Affordable Requirements Ordinance? ARO units are notoriously difficult for renters to find. The city publishes an ARO buildings database but people who qualify for an ARO apartment must contact each building manager individually to ascertain availability. A registry designed with these uses in mind from the start could solve so many longstanding issues with finding housing.

Where things stand

PRO is still a work in progress and the ordinance text hasn’t been finalized. The city has been briefing advocacy organizations and apartment industry groups to gather feedback, and is hoping to introduce the ordinance in late June.

I’ll write more as the ordinance advances. The rental registry is the piece I care most about in this series — it’s the data foundation without which the rest of PRO is difficult to enforce.

My testimony to the Illinois House’s executive community in favor of the BUILD plan

Today the Illinois House executive committee is having a subject matter hearing about Gov. Pritzker’s BUILD plan, which was introduced to the House by Rep. Kam Buckner as HB5626. Because the oral testimony list for today’s meeting was getting too long I was asked to submit my testimony in writing instead.

Thank you for inviting me to speak. My name is Steven Vance, and I am a volunteer lead Abundant Housing Illinois, a pro-housing advocacy group.

I would like to describe what a housing shortage looks like in Northeastern Illinois using two examples from current listings.

  • A 3-bedroom apartment in Evanston was listed earlier this year at $2,900 a month and advertised a move-in fee of 40% of the rent — $1,160 on top of the first month. The move-in fee is a percentage of rent so as rents rise, so would that fee.
  • A western suburban apartment building charges $75 in application fees, $300 in administrative fees, and a move-in fee that ranges between $250 and $500, depending on the applicant’s credit.

At the onset, this may not seem like a housing shortage issue, but this is what landlords can charge when renters have few options. One of the solutions for this is increasing their competition.

The Illinois legislature is the right venue to make changes to allow more housing. The case for state action rests on a structural mismatch: housing markets are regional, but zoning is local. When a single municipality blocks new homes, it pushes demand elsewhere, raising prices across a region and displacing people, or forcing them into longer commutes or out of Illinois altogether. Additionally, in the rare event that a community allows more homebuilding, pent up demand can be overwhelming. State-level reform spreads pressure evenly and equitably over neighborhoods across the state.

The study by Illinois Economic Policy Institute found that Illinois is roughly 142,000 homes short of where it needs to be, and we’re building at barely half the pace required to catch up. Every Illinoisan pays for that, but individual municipalities aren’t incentivized to fix it. Even the willing municipalities can’t solve it alone: a few good actors out of hundreds doesn’t aggregate into a sufficient response.

Some of the legislature’s responsibilities include growing our economy, spurring good jobs, and keeping the tax base healthy to fund schools, transit, and healthcare. Housing scarcity undermines all of that.

The people most harmed by scarcity — the family priced out, the senior who can’t downsize, the next generation that hasn’t moved here yet — don’t get to voice their support for housing at each village’s plan commission hearings. They are not always local constituents, but they are yours.

That Illinois has a housing shortage isn’t in serious dispute. The question this body faces is how to act on it. BUILD isn’t coming out of nowhere; in 2020, for example, there was an accessory dwelling unit bill introduced, and other housing legalization bills were introduced in the last two years. The BUILD plan creates a coherent statewide framework, pairs it with $250 million in capital funding for infrastructure, middle housing construction, and down payment assistance. BUILD is a comprehensive proposal created at a time when the politics to reduce the housing shortage should finally be aligned. 

A century ago Illinois delegated zoning authority to municipalities. The legislature has the right and responsibility to set a floor for allowing more housing when that delegation produces statewide harm. BUILD sets that floor, and adopting it is a job only this body can do and what our over 530 members are asking you to do. .

Thank you for your time and attention.

A day in Springfield with Abundant Housing Illinois

Earlier this month I made the trip down to Springfield to volunteer with Abundant Housing Illinois, an advocacy organization pushing for more housing options across the state. It was our biggest group ever, with 39 people going from five Illinois municipalities, and most of us took Amtrak there and back.

The day was a mix of orientation, refining our housing stories and why we volunteer, and then walking the halls of the Capitol to speak with legislators and their staff. Our housing advocates talked to twenty Illinois General Assembly members about reforming local codes that prevent people from being able to afford housing all over the state. We spoke in support of the BUILD plan I wrote about earlier.

It’s important – although inefficient – to show up in person and make the case directly. The legislators we met with were highly or quite receptive, though you never quite know what interactions or talking points will actually move the needle. All of the six bills in the BUILD plan have not yet passed committee; but that doesn’t stop them from moving forward through other means.

If you care about housing in Illinois — whether that’s affordability, supply, or just the ability to build an ADU in your backyard — Abundant Housing Illinois is worth knowing about. Join us!